Setting up humanists as straw men for the fall of the Western world is
as easy as shooting literati in a barrel. But that ease may result more
from the form than the content of humanists' beliefs. In the
humanities, scholars usually do their research alone. Scientists, on
the other hand, are trained to work in groups. Little wonder, then,
that the humanities now features a full-blown academic celebrity
culture. In order for celebrities to exist, people have to be willing
to look up as well as down -- and looking both ways can promote
insecurity.
-- Leonard Cassuto
"A Humanist's Sojourn Among Scientists"
Chronicle of Higher Education
May 2, 2003 Volume 49, Issue 34, Page B5
The work of a historian is to tell stories. The work of a literary
critic is to interpret them. It's inherently approachable -- until
recently. The last two generations have seen the pursuits of humanists
take on their own quasi-scientific aspects, complete with highly
technical jargon. Attempts to popularize have often been met with the
special hostility that attends defense of hierarchy -- consider the
philosopher Judith Butler's assertion on the op-ed page of The New York
Times that her ideas were so complex they couldn't be expressed in away
that regular people might understand.
-- Leonard Cassuto
"A Humanist's Sojourn Among Scientists"
Chronicle of Higher Education
May 2, 2003 Volume 49, Issue 34, Page B5
The story of the Bell Labs physics scandal initially intrigued me
because I thought it might turn out to be a scientific version of the
culture wars, with scientists coming under attack from groups that help
finance them. It didn't turn out that way. The data turned out to be
faked, the perpetrator was fired, and the ripples from the scandal were
contained within the physics world. But humanists have long been
embroiled in their own conflicts with the society that finances them --
and one of the reasons lies in the way that we raise roadblocks and bar
the world from entering our neighborhood. That's the opposite of what
we ought to be doing, and it's all the more shameful because humanists
are in an unusual and enviable position: The nature of our work makes
it easy to open our doors and share that work. We can start doing so in
the simplest way: by being nicer.
-- Leonard Cassuto
"A Humanist's Sojourn Among Scientists"
Chronicle of Higher Education
May 2, 2003 Volume 49, Issue 34, Page B5